top of page
  • Emily Beresford

Great Tips on How to design a Challenge Coin - Custom Challenge Coins

Pantone Colors, Design Charts on Desk.

What to consider when designing Custom Challenge Coins

When most people think of challenge coins, the first thing that comes to mind is military service. But challenge coins have a long and varied history, with many different purposes beyond honoring those who serve in the military. In fact, custom challenge coins can be made for any group or organization, and can feature any design you choose. Our team at has some great tips to consider when designing your own custom challenge coin.

1. Understand the History and Purpose of Challenge Coins

Challenge coins have their origins in ancient Rome, where soldiers were given medals as a sign of valor and courage. In more recent times, challenge coins have been used as a way to promote camaraderie and esprit de corps within military units. Today, challenge coins are still used by the military, but they have also become popular within law enforcement, firefighting, and other first responder organizations, as well as businesses, clubs, and schools.

2. Consider the Design Elements that will Make your Challenge Coin Unique

When designing your custom challenge coin, there are a few things to keep in mind. First, you’ll want to choose a shape and size for your coin that is appropriate for your purpose. Challenge coins typically range in size from 1.5 inches to 2.5 inches, but they can be larger or smaller if you prefer. You’ll also want to decide on the metal you’d like your coin to be made from. Gold, silver, and bronze are all popular choices, but there are a wide variety of other metals available as well.

Contact us button

Coming up with a Challenge Coin Idea

When it comes to challenge coins, the sky is the limit in terms of design. However, coming up with the perfect challenge coin idea can be a challenge in itself. Visit our gallery for some inspiration ideas as well as here are a few things to keep in mind when brainstorming challenge coin ideas:

  • Who will be receiving the challenge coin? This is important to consider, as the design should be relevant to the recipient. For example, challenge coins for military members may feature patriotic imagery, while challenge coins for law enforcement officers may feature an image of a badge.

  • What is the purpose and role of the challenge coin? Is it meant to commemorate a special event or achievement? Or is it simply a token of appreciation? The answer to this question will help guide the design process.

  • What type of artwork would be most appropriate? Challenge coins can feature intricate designs, symbols, and even photos. Keep in mind that simpler designs are often more impactful, so don’t feel like you have to cram everything into one small space.

  • What statement do you want your custom coins to make about your organization and its vision and values? Challenge coins remind us that we are all part of something larger than ourselves, and that by working together, we can accomplish great things.

  • They also serve as a reminder that no challenge is too great for us to overcome, and that no goal is out of reach.

  • Challenge coins are more than just a piece of metal - they are a symbol of who we are and what we stand for: camaraderie, teamwork, dedication and service.

By keeping these factors in mind, you’ll be well on your way to creating a challenge coin that is both meaningful and memorable.

Challenge Coin - All Custom Sizes and Shapes

Challenge coins come in all shapes and sizes. While the most popular challenge coin size is the standard one-and-a-half inch coin, challenge coins can range from one to three inches in diameter.

The size of a challenge coin is often dictated by its purpose. For example, larger challenge coins are often used as desk or display pieces, while smaller challenge coins can be easily carried and stored.

Challenge Coin Opener in 3 sizes with a quarter as size reference.

The shape of a challenge coin is also important. The most popular challenge coin shape is the round coin, but challenge coins can also be square, rectangular, or even triangular.

The shape of a challenge coin often reflects the logo or design that is featured on the coin. For example, challenge coins that feature a eagle design are often shaped like an oval to better showcase the bird’s wingspan. Ultimately, the size and shape of a challenge coin should be chosen based on the needs of the individual or organization.

Weight, Texture & Look and Feel of your Challenge Coin

A challenge coin is a thick, heavy coin with a high-quality finish. They are often made of brass or other metal, and they can be very valuable. The weight and texture of challenge coins are very important. They need to be hefty enough to feel substantial, but not so heavy that they are inconvenient to carry.

The finish should be smooth and glossy, without any roughness or imperfections. Challenge coins are often used as currency in games or as gifts for special occasions. Getting the weight and texture just right is essential for creating a beautiful and valuable challenge coin.

Adding 3D to your Challenge Coin Artwork & Design

Challenge coins come in a variety of shapes and sizes, but one of the most unique and eye-catching designs is 3D challenge coin artwork. 3D challenge coin artwork is created by sculpting into the metal surface of the coin, adding depth and dimension to the design.

This type of challenge coin is perfect for those who want their coin to really stand out from the rest. Whether you're looking for a one-of-a-kind gift or a conversation starter for your next networking event, 3D challenge coin artwork is a great optional extra.

Designing with Enamel Colors

When it comes to challenge coins, there are a few things to consider when it comes to the enamel colors. While there are many different color options available, some of the most popular colors chosen by challenge coin collectors are those that match the color palette of popular brands, such as Pantone.

Custom Fire Chief Challenge Coin with Pantone Color Chart & PMS Colors.

While there are many different ways to incorporate Pantone colors into challenge coins, some of the most popular methods include using PMS colors on both the coin face and edge, as well as using a Pantone-themed coin design. Regardless of how you choose to incorporate Pantone colors into your challenge coins, doing so is a great way to add an extra layer of personalization and style to your coins.

Metal Plating Options for Challenge Coins

There are many different metal plating options for challenge coins, including gold, silver, bronze, and copper. Gold and silver challenge coins are the most common, but bronze and copper challenge coins are also popular choices. Each metal has its own unique benefits and drawbacks, so it's important to choose the right metal for your challenge coin.

Gold challenge coins have a classic look and feel, and they're very durable. Silver challenge coins are less expensive than gold challenge coins, and they have a bright, shiny finish. Bronze challenge coins have a antique look and feel, and they're very strong. Copper challenge coins are the least expensive option, but they're not as durable as other metals.

Custom Edging Options for Coins

Custom challenge coins are a popular way to promote and show allegiance to a cause, company, or military unit. They are also a popular souvenir and collectible item. At we offer a variety of different edging options to add a unique look to your custom coin.

3 Most Popular Challenge Coin Edges, Standard, Rope and Bezel.

Beveled edging is a popular choice for challenge coins because it gives the coin a 3D look and feel. This type of edging is achieved by angled cuts on the edge of the coin. Another popular edging option is scalloped edging. This type of edging is achieved by adding curved cuts along the edge of the coin. Scalloped edging can give your challenge coin a more elegant look.

Finally, serrated edging is another option that is achieved by adding saw-tooth like cuts along the edge of the coin. Serrated edging can give your challenge coin a more aggressive look. Choose the right edging option to match your challenge coin design and create a truly unique keepsake.

Packaging Options for Challenge Coins

When it comes to challenge coins, there are a variety of packaging options to choose from. One option is a basic coin pouch. This is a small, affordable option that can be used to protect your challenge coin while not in use.

Another option is a coin case. These cases are typically made from acrylic or plastic, and they offer more protection for your challenge coin. They come in a variety of sizes, so you can choose one that fits your challenge coin collection.

Finally, you can also opt for a custom challenge coin display. These displays can be made from a variety of materials, and they allow you to show off your challenge coin collection in style. No matter which option you choose, challenge coins make a great addition to any collection.

3. Choose a Reputable Challenge Coin Manufacturer

Once you’ve designed your coin, it’s time to find the right manufacturer to produce it. When choosing a manufacturer, it’s important to select one that is experienced in making challenge coins and that offers a high-quality product. has over 30 years of experience and a talented staff and is the best Challenge Coin company to help you on every step of your custom coin journey. Our designers will use their knowledge and expertise to create a beautiful coin design just for you based on your suggestions and specifications. We don't charge for art or changes. We'll make sure that the size and type of coin you choose produces a stunning final product.

4. Requesting Quote, Artwork & Approve the Final Design Before Production Begins

At RespondersPro we know that when it comes to designing custom challenge coins, the options are endless. Send us your sketches, artwork, notes, PMS Color choices and all of the little details and extras that will make your coin unique.

Our team of designers is experienced in creating stunning custom challenge coin designs, and we'll work with you to make sure that your final product is exactly what you had in mind. We will create a detailed visual proof of your one of a kind custom coin including PSM Colors for your input and approval. Our team is happy to make any revisions or changes as needed. Once you have approved the proof, production of your challenge coins begins!

5. Sit Back, Relax & Enjoy your Custom Challenge Coin!

Once your challenge coins have been produced, it’s time to enjoy them! Custom challenge coins make great gifts, souvenirs, or simply a way to show your pride in your organization or group. Challenge coins can also be collected, and many people display their challenge coin collections in shadow boxes or other creative ways. Whatever your purpose for creating custom challenge coins, ensures that the process is simple, clear and enjoyable. So get started designing your own today!

Request Quote button

First Responder Challenge Coins Made Easy

Ready, Set, Order & Buy Custom Challenge Coins - No Minimum!

With years of experience and expertise behind us, has been privileged to working with First Responders in all branches of Law Enforcement, City Departments, Universities, Schools, EMT’s and Paramedics, Corporations in every state in the USA, throughout Canada and Internationally. Law Enforcement Challenge Coins are suited perfectly to recognition, recruitment, team building and commemorative events and milestone.

Our RespondersPro team proudly designs and creates custom challenge coins, custom medallions & medals, custom lapel pins, belt buckles for:

· Police Departments

· Law Enforcement Agencies

· Sheriff Departments

· EMS Services

· Military, Armed Services, Coast Guard

· Corporations

· Schools, Universities, Colleges

· Sports Teams & Sport Associations

Please contact our team for your free quote at Our specialist team is always on hand to work with you to create a beautiful and lasting challenge coin design that showcases honor, respect and achievements for a lifetime. We are very pleased to offer our Limited Time Offer - A Presentation Wooden Coin Display Box for your Chief.

We look forward to working with you to celebrate your outstanding achievements with your order of Custom Challenge Coins, Medallions, Custom Patches and Lapel Pins.

Contact RespondersPro today to get started on your custom challenge coin project! Logo, Contact Information, Phone Number and Email.


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page